Auto-Renewal & Subscription Laws: FTC Click-to-Cancel and State Rules

If your e-commerce business offers subscriptions, memberships, or any form of automatic recurring billing, you're subject to a complex web of federal and state auto-renewal laws. Non-compliance can result in chargebacks, AG enforcement, and class action lawsuits.

Federal: the FTC Click-to-Cancel rule

The FTC's updated Negative Option Rule (commonly called "Click-to-Cancel") requires that cancellation must be at least as easy as sign-up. Key requirements:

• Consumers must be able to cancel through the same method they used to subscribe (online sign-up = online cancellation).
• No "save" screens, phone calls, or extra hoops before cancellation is processed.
• Clear disclosure of all material terms before the consumer agrees to subscribe.
• Affirmative express informed consent before charging.

Key state laws

• **California ARL (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 17600-17606)** — One of the strictest. Requires clear disclosure, affirmative consent, acknowledgment email, and an online cancellation mechanism. Violations can result in $2,500+ per occurrence.
• **New York GBL § 527** — Requires clear disclosure of auto-renewal terms and an easy cancellation method.
• **Illinois (815 ILCS 601)** — Requires written disclosure and consumer acknowledgment before charging.
• **Oregon, Virginia, Colorado, Delaware** — All have specific auto-renewal statutes with varying requirements.

Compliance checklist

1. **Clear pre-purchase disclosure** of auto-renewal terms, including price, frequency, and cancellation method. 2. **Affirmative consent** — a separate checkbox or clear agreement step, not buried in terms. 3. **Confirmation email** with renewal terms and cancellation instructions. 4. **Easy online cancellation** — no phone calls, no chat queues, no dark patterns. 5. **Pre-renewal reminder** — some states require notification before each renewal.

---

**Disclaimer:** This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified attorney for advice specific to your business.